Monday, August 23, 2010

Kashmir-Himaliyan Blunders Continued

The biggest mistake India committed on the Kashmir front is not to refer the issue to UN and declare ceasefire or accepting the demand for plebiscite. However the biggest blunder was to accept the invitation of Maharaja Hari Singh and send the troops to Kashmir valley.
Although reluctantly our leaders accepted Jinha's theory of two nations and given consent to partition of India and the principal on which India was partitioned between India and Pakistan was religious majority. That's how Punjab and Bengal were divided.
Sighting the same principal, we did not allowed Nizam of Hydrabad and Nawab of Junhagarh were not allowed to join the Pakistan. So India had no legitimate claim whatsoever on Kashmir Valley. At the most it could have staked the claim on Jammu and Laddakh.
But once we accepted the invitation to send the troops to Kashmir, we left the business of occupying the Kashmir unfinished and created the trouble for ourselves, which we don't know, how to tackle, even after 63 years of Independence.
This also clearly shows, there was no well thought out strategy behind sending troops to Kashmir. There were no clear political objectives set by India's then rulers when they sent the troops to take on so called tribal militia. After all war is a diplomacy by other means.
When China decided to occupy Tibet, political objective was clear, it wanted to create buffer between itself and its mighty Western neighbour India (This may sound ridiculous in today's circumstances, but back then we were on the same page with China both in terms of economic and military might. In fact India's army was better trained and armed thanks to British rule).
Then another mistake we made was, we made no attempts to change the demography of Kashmir as China did with Tibet. In fact we went on to add Article 370 in the constitution and ensured weed of separatism never dies down in the valley.
Having said this, now only practical and honourable solution to both India and Pakistan to solve the problem is to accept the LOC as the international border and settle the issue for once. We were close to achieve this goal during Indira-Bhutto talks after the Bangladesh war but wasted the opportunity and allowed the enemy to go lightly like good Hindus.
But now, we must not waste any time and arrive at settlement on Kashmir issue at earliest and move on. We can't allow our nation to bleed and hamper our economic progress and more importantly, if we remain too preoccupied with Kashmir and Pakistan, we may never able to prepare ourselves to take on the next big challenge before us i.e. China.

5 comments:

  1. Hi makarand. first let me congratulate you for starting a blog. please circulate the link among all your friends. I agree with almost all of what you said. Clearly, the China danger is for all to see and we can't take it lightly at all despite what Jairam Ramesh says. But, we have to give it to Pakistan's diplomacy that they have managed to handle US and India well while cultivating China. They have also milked the US using the fear psychosis over Pakistan's internal collapse and the safety of its nuke arsenal.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Makrand, great that you started a blog. Congratulations.

    Why stop at accepting LOC as international border ? we can give it all away. We are past masters at giving up.

    Pakistan is far better a player than us. Look at the way they are scoring over us in Afghanistan.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Makrand,Congrats that you started a blog.What about US its favouring all the time to pakistan
    in every aspect

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with you when you say that as per the logic of partition Kashmir should have gone to Pak. But what messed up the things was Harisingh's
    dream of independent state; Sheikh Abdullah's wavering, and Nehru's attachment to his native land.
    Insurgency would have come anyway, I believe. Religion is a terrible force. Changing demography takes a lot of brutality; I wouldn't want my country to do what Stalin did in Soviet Russia.

    ReplyDelete
  5. grt macro and congrts. keep it up.

    Bahadurshah Jafar once said:--
    Bajuome bu hogi jabtalak imanki
    tab to London tak chalegi teg hindustanki

    unfortuantely, thanks to our diplomats, the teg has been prevented from crossing the LOC.

    ReplyDelete